Are you skeptical of the Angel Light?
Date: Sunday, January 23, 2005 @ 16:55:24 UTC
Topic: Devices


From the free_energy@yahoogroups.com: On Jan 21, 2005, at 6:33 AM, Bill Hamilton wrote:

To Scientists and Engineers,

If you do not think the Angel Light can work, would you be willing to make a statement, giving the relevant theoretical reasons why not?

Here is a message from Phil Novak asking:


__________
Hi Bill:

Thanks for the Hall's email address. Charles will be getting back to me.

What I'd like to do now, something I should have done from the start, is present the other side of the coin.

Perhaps you know a scientist who can also write in layman's terms who could prepare a guest column on "Why the Angel Light couldn't possibly work" based on what's in my article. Or perhaps, a compilation of learned opinion you've collected on your site.

Of course, whomever contributes would have to allow their real names and positions be included for validity's sake.

What do you think?

Phil Novak

Contact BayToday.ca
News Department

Phil Novak, News Director
E-mail: phil@baytoday.ca
Phone: (705) 497-9619
Fax: (705) 497-9671
_______

Bill Hamilton
AstroScience Research

"I don't see the logic of rejecting data just because they seem incredible." Fred Hoyle

---------------------

From: Jack Sarfatti
Date: January 21, 2005 2:30:35 PM PST
Subject: Re: Are you skeptical of the Angel Light?


The claim is so ludicrous that only a complete scientific illiterate would fall for it. No serious scientist will waste time on it at this point. This only proves that people are stupider than I thought possible.

Jack Sarfatti
----------------

From: Victor Martinez
Date: 2005/01/21 Fri PM 10:19:57 EST
Subject: Are you skeptical of the Angel Light? Not me and Professor Warwick!

Professor H:

I think it's great that you solicited comment, review and input form those in the scientific/engineering community, BUT you should NOT have directed any such inquiry to a close-minded humanoid like Jack "Wacko Jacko" Sarfatti who -- since Star Trek IV -- has lost his ablity to "think outside the box" and consider the IMpossible possible.

Professor Warwick cautioned me yesterday against "provoking Sarfatti with his disintegrating mind suffering the throes of presenile dementia," and judging from his attached childlike response, I think you may have provoked him into one of his Islamo-fascist-like rants!

I know nothing of physics, so I deferred to Professor Warwick's keen, analytical scientific mind and he gave the "Angel Light" his 'Good Housekeeping' stamp of approval, so that's good enough for me,... who does Sarfatti think we are,... scientific illiterates?!

If you REALLY want to know how the "Angel Light" machine weighs in the minds of REAL physicists -- not ones laden with frontal lobe atrophy -- ask the following well-known, respected physicists:

Dr Harold E Puthoff
Dr Russell E Targ
Dr Karl Pribram
Dr Bernard Haisch
Dr Fred Alan Wolf
Dr Bruce Maccabee
Dr James Deardorff
Stan T Friedman
---------------

On Jan 21, 2005, at 7:37 PM, Eric Krieg wrote:

I don't know how wacked out Jack Sarfatti is. Much of his "advanced physics" are simply beyond my training - so I don't feel qualified to really comment on them. I guess the same goes for some of Puthoff's. There are many who read extreme physics and just pretend to understand. Sarfatti is rather caustic, but has pointed out a lot of raving theorist-wannabes with nothing to offer.

I have people who throw extreme physics theory at me on a regular basis - I am just not interested in it. I will take an extreme physics theory of everything seriously when backed by a significant really running device.

I think a here-and-now device that makes energy out of thin air or can see through a brick wall is of interest and worth taking a look at. I have been offering a 10,000$ prize for real proof of free energy for 8 years now. I have a constant flux of people who rant that their device will soon win it. I find that after they get through berating mainstream science, frothing about some big conspiracy and bleating about the huge world impact of their ideas . . . they never get around to offering a real demonstration of their earth shattering ideas.

My prize conditions are found at: http://www.phact.org/e/freetest.html

I would love to pay out the money and help elevate a possible real claimant above the din of legions of kooks and con man who have been asserting the same claim for many decades. Many of the latter are listed off at http://www.phact.org/e/dennis4.html

I have found there are always press people who are happy to promote an astounding claim with little more evidence than the inventors assertion and a peice of equipment that doesn't run. If anyone sees real first hand quality evidence for this Angel device, please let me know.

Eric Krieg
--------------

From: Jack Sarfatti
Date: 2005/01/22 Sat PM 12:27:02 EST
Subject: Re: Are you skeptical of the Angel Light? Not me and Professor Warwick!

I agree with Erick. Martinez is a scientific Mrs Malaprop with no critical judgment with a very low signal to noise ratio. When he comes up with something of interest it is a rare event.

Also, on another issue raised by Kit, there is no credible experimental evidence for the detection of isolated magnetic monopoles. The Russian claims to the contrary are bogus. Of course there are MANY theory papers on magnetic monopoles and I never implied that there were not. Inflation cosmology predicts about one monopole per Hubble universe.

The probability of a real "Angel Light" is too low for me to waste time on such an extraordinary claim at this moment _ especially since the guy seems to have no credentials and got his idea in a dream.

If corroboration by credible people is forthcoming I will take a look. BTW Puthoff is credible in this instance. Let Hal check it out. My ONLY beef with Puthoff is on his bad physics theories on PV gravity and zero point energy. Note I say "bad" not "bogus" a key distinction. I support Puthoff's work on RV at SRI for example. Puthoff is basically an engineer - an applied laser physicist. Puthoff is NOT A THEORETICAL PHYSICIST in spacetime physics by education.

WE THEORISTS ARE A BREED APART. Haisch even less so. Haisch is an experimental astronomer WITH NO ADVANCED THEORETICAL TRAINING and a Lockheed Manager type. I know Bernie and Hal personally and Bernie admits he has no deep understanding the theory he espouses. Rueda and others do all the math work on Bernie's team papers on zero point energy.

The consensus of top people at GR 17 was thumbs down on the PV & ZPE theoretical physics that both Hal and Bernie are selling to the media using naive journalists like Nick Cook and others. Professor Robert Park of AIP has written about this. He is a Big Shot Professor at University of Maryland Physics Department. While I do not like Park and I actually do like Hal, nevertheless Park is correct in his review of Nick Cook's "The Hunt for Zero Point". This is nothing personal, its professionalism. If it were personal I would attack Park who I do not like and would defend Hal who I do like. But OBJECTIVE TRUTH and INTEGRITY force me not to do that.

On the other hand I DO NOT ATTACK Hal's paranormal work. That is a different story. Also I am not as competent in that field. Also Fred Alan Wolf and I are very close friends for more than 30 years. Fred would be open minded on Angel Light but if he were to really study it I bet he would reject it. I bet Hal Puthoff will also reject it if he investigates it.







This article comes from ZPEnergy.com
http://www.zpenergy.com

The URL for this story is:
http://www.zpenergy.com/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=1132