 |
There are currently, 260 guest(s) and 0 member(s) that are online.
You are Anonymous user. You can register for free by clicking here
| |
|  |
Scientific Analysis of Rossi, Focardi and Levi Claims
Posted on Sunday, July 31, 2011 @ 22:06:13 UTC by vlad
|
|
 July 30,
2011
New Energy Times #37 and Rossi Report #3
– Scientific Analysis of
Rossi, Focardi and Levi Claims
Issue 37 of New Energy Times is available. It includes
"Report #3: Scientific Analysis of Rossi, Focardi and Levi Claims."
This
is the third in a series of reports about Andrea Rossi, creator of a device he
calls the Energy Catalyzer, or E-Cat, Sergio Focardi, professor emeritus at the
University of Bologna, and Giuseppe Levi, a professor in the university's
Department of Physics and their claims of a low-energy nuclear reaction device
that produces commercially useful levels of excess heat.
Does Rossi's device produce heat beyond that which is possible by chemistry? The
device may produce some excess heat, but not nearly at the levels claimed by
Rossi and his collaborators. In fact, the heat released from the experiment
appears to be several orders of magnitude less than what they have claimed, at
best.
Last year, Rossi and Focardi claimed an energy gain of 213 times.
This year, Rossi downgraded that to six. Our analysis shows a possible energy
gain of one to two times. In other words, Rossi's device probably produces
Watts, not kilowatts, of power. It may, in fact, produce zero excess heat. We
cannot know with confidence because of the poor data collection and
reporting.
Report #3 reviews the scientific facts in
detail.
Click
Here to go to New Energy Times #37 and Rossi Report #3
|
| |
|
Don't have an account yet? You can create one. As a registered user you have some advantages like theme manager, comments configuration and post comments with your name.
| |
|
|
No Comments Allowed for Anonymous, please register |
|
What a cold fusion theory must be able to do? (Score: 1) by vlad on Sunday, July 31, 2011 @ 22:12:33 UTC (User Info | Send a Message) http://www.zpenergy.com | WGUGLINSKI writes: Some years ago, Edmund Storms wrote me the following:
''For a
model to be useful, it must tell me what elements I should mix, at what
concentrations, and in what physical enviroment to make the process
occur in a predicted way. [...] . Unfortunatelly, no model provides the
answer at the present time''.
Let's analyze what he claims.
There is today a great mystery in cold fusion field: the element used at catalyst in Andrea Rossi's E-Cat.
In Peswiki website, Hank Mills wrote: ''It
is interesting to hear that Rossi is sharing more information about the
nickel powder and the catalysts. For a very long time he refused to
discuss the catalysts at all, except to say they are not radioactive,
cheap, and commonly available. Maybe more information about the
catalysts will be revealed in the coming months. There has been a
great deal of speculation on the internet about the identities of the
catalysts. One good place to read such speculation is on the Vortex-L
mailing list. Although there are many guesses, no one appears to really
know without a doubt the identities of the catalysts.'' http://pesn.com/2011/07/14/9501868_E-Cat_news_coming_fast_and_furious/ [www.zpenergy.comindex.php?url=http%3A%2F%2Fpesn.com%2F2011%2F07%2F14%2F9501868_E-Cat_news_coming_fast_and_furious%2F]
Andrea Rossi is even considering using a self-destruct device in his E-Cat, in case someone tries to open it - when his invention goes to market.
On
another hand, there are several cold fusion theories nowadays. And
except Quantum Ring Theory, no one of them was able to predict what is
the element used as catalyst in the E-Cat.
Note that the
situation is NOT so difficult as considered by Edmund Storms. Indeed,
look at in the same Peswiki link what Hank Mills wrote: ''Andrea
Rossi is still working on several elements an substances to improve the
catalysts for the Hydrogen-Nickel reaction, and he has been doing so for
the past four, five years. The most effective catalyst found so far,
was at one stage abandoned in the search for an even more effective one,
but was later reinstated because, overall, it proved to be the most
effective one.''
Therefore, it's not the case of to predict what
elements one should mix, at what concentrations, and in what physical
enviroment to make the process occur in a predicted way. Actually it's an easier task: it's the case to predict only what is the best element that proved to be the most effective one.
And
in spite of there are many cold fusion theories today, their authors
did not succeed to discover the element used by Andrea Rossi. So we
realize that Edmund Storms - and the most cold fusion researchers - have
not a satisfactory comprehension of what a cold fusion theory must be
able to do - of course in the present situation of our understanding
about cold fusion.
The best element to be most effective used by Andrea Rossi was predicted in my paper ”How repulsive gravity contributes for cold fusion in Rossi-Focardi experiment”. In July 16th, Andrea Rossi replied to me in his blog: ''Dear Wladimir Guglinski, You
are very good in this science and I am sure you are making very good
things. I am sure you are among those who are or will be able to
replicate my effect studying the patent. Warmest Regards, my friend. And a hug to Brazil! A.R.'' http://www.journal-of-nuclear-physics.com/?p=462#comments [www.zpenergy.comindex.php?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.journal-of-nuclear-physics.com%2F%3Fp%3D462%23comments]
I
promised to Andrea Rossi do not reveal the element, because he is
afraid his invention can be stolen by his competitors before he get the
patent.
But now lets think about the most interested point concerning the cold fusion theories.
Those
ones that know my Quantum Ring Theory, and my new nuclear model, know
that I have tried to understand cold fusion by a qualitative viewpoint,
in order to discover the mechanisms that take place in cold fusion
occurrence. And those ones that now my QRT may realize that there is
no way, in the present moment, to apply Edmund Storms criterium by using
my theory, because there is need to discover several paramenters that
rule the working of my new nuclear model, so that to obtain the
equations for the New Nuclear Theory which must be developed from my new
nuclear model.
Now suppose that my new nuclear model is correct,
in spite of we do not have yet the suitable equations to be used for
predictions with this model. Well, if my model is really correct, then think about the following:
-
do you think there is any chance for the theorists to get a
satisfactory cold fusion theory, capable to fulfill the Edmund Storm
criterium ?
Obviously the answer is NO. Because my theory tries to understand cold fusion by trying to discover the qualitative MECHANISMS which
take place in cold fusion occurrence. And one of those mechanisms is
the participation of the repulsive gravity, which would explain how the
Coulombic barrier is surpassed by the particles.
Therefore, if my theory is correct, the theorists will never be able to undersand cold fusion, and they will be forever banging their heads against the wall, trying the impossible: to understand cold fusion by using their wrong nuclear models, and their equations not suitable to be applied to cold fusion.
Their unique chance to be successful is the following: the new nuclear model proposed in Quantum Ring Theory must be wrong.
Who knows the true ?
So
that to be successfull to explain cold fusion with their theories, the
other authors have to pray to God, keeping the hope that my QRT is
wrong...
Maybe... in spite of the many experimental
corroborations to my Quantum Ring Theory in the last years between 2009
and 2011... my theory can be wrong
And maybe my theory is wrong ... despite my correct prediction of the catalyst used by Andrea Rossi in his E-Cat, a prediction obtained thanks to my new nuclear model... a feat that other authors have failed...
In short, we have to wait. The future will give us the answer ...
Perhaps,
after many years of unsuccessful attempts, the cold
fusion researchers will finally stop pretending that Quantum Ring Theory
does not exist, as they are doing nowadays. |
|
|
Re: Scientific Analysis of Rossi, Focardi and Levi Claims (Score: 1) by Koen on Saturday, August 06, 2011 @ 00:54:12 UTC (User Info | Send a Message) http://no.nl/tesla | I read the report http://newenergytimes.com/v2/news/2011/37/3705report3.shtml#hoax
It is disappointing that Rossi's claims are way to optimistic. Remains the question: is it solid state fusion or not? Other researchers than Rossi Focardi and Levi have been occupied with serious LENR Ni-H fusion research, and have reported positive results, but not the extraordinary performance as claimed by Rossi.
So what is going on, maybe Rossi's claims are part of just another hoax in order to discredit the serious researchers of the LENR community? Report #3 is disappointing to say the least.
Now I only would like to know what catalyst for the LENR Ni-H reaction was predicted by Wladimir Guglinski's very interesting 'quantum ring' theory...
|
|
|
Rossi’s Scientific Failure in Seven Steps (Score: 1) by vlad on Tuesday, August 09, 2011 @ 22:08:43 UTC (User Info | Send a Message) http://www.zpenergy.com | From New Energy Times blog: http://blog.newenergytimes.com/2011/08/07/rossis-scientific-failure-in-seven-steps/ [blog.newenergytimes.com]
Rossi’s Scientific Failure in Seven Steps
[This article is Copyleft 2011 New Energy Times [newenergytimes.com].
Permission is granted to reproduce this article as long as the article,
this notice and the publication information are included in their
entirety and no changes are made to this article.]
Andrea Rossi is the creator of a device he calls the Energy
Catalyzer, or E-Cat. Together with Sergio Focardi, professor emeritus at
the University of Bologna, and Giuseppe Levi, a professor in the
university’s Department of Physics, the trio claimed a low-energy
nuclear reaction device that produced extraordinarily large amounts of
excess heat. In fact, Rossi had promoted the idea as a
soon-to-be-available commercial device. The complete list of New Energy Times reports on this topic is here [newenergytimes.com].
The Rossi group’s primary energy claim was based on its assertion
that virtually all inlet water vaporized into steam. The group had two
primary measurement methods from which to choose.
Method 1 was to perform condensing calorimetry to measure the heat
output directly. The group made no such measurements. The
characteristics of steam output observed in the June 14, 2011, and April
28, 2011, experiments were consistent with much lower levels of heat
output than the group claimed.
Method 2, which the group attempted, was to confirm that no
unvaporized water left the device. This method required the group to
check two things. First, it needed to measure steam quality to confirm
that no unvaporized water left in the form of tiny droplets. However,
the group used a device that, according to the manufacturer, was not
designed or suitable for measuring steam quality. That device was
designed to measure only the humidity of air. The group also needed to
check that liquid water did not flow out of the device and down the
drain. It did not attempt to check this.
Thus, the group had no accurate measurements of the heat output or
the quality of steam produced and therefore no experimental evidence on
which to base its extraordinary energy claim.
The group ran one experiment below the boiling point of water;
however, it did not write and does not intend to release a report on the
results of that test.
Seven Steps
1. Rossi Group’s Extraordinary Claim About Energy Production
The Rossi group’s primary energy claim was based on its assertion that virtually all inlet water vaporized into steam.
2. Video Recordings of Steam Production
The characteristics of steam output observed in the June 14, 2011, and
April 28, 2011, experiments are consistent with substantial amounts of
unvaporized inlet water present in the output. This means that the
experiments produced much lower levels of heat output than the group
claimed.
3. Presence of Unvaporized Water in Device Output
-Water can leave as liquid by overflowing through the outlet hose.
-Water can leave as tiny droplets, thus lowering steam quality.
4. No Condensing Calorimetry to Measure Heat Directly (Method 1)
No condensing calorimetry measurements were performed to measure the heat output directly.
5. Claims of Steam Quality Measurements (Method 2)
The Rossi group claimed to have accurately measured steam quality. The
chemist it used to perform these measurements did not use a detector
that was designed for or capable of measuring steam quality. The group
also needed to check that liquid water did not flow out of the device
and down the drain. It did not attempt to check this, and thus any steam
quality measurement was irrelevant.
6. Device Used to Attempt Steam Quality Measurement (Method 2)
- Question to manufacturer: “What is the capability of this device to measure steam quality?”
- Response from manufacturer: “None. It is not suited for steam quality measurement.”
7. Conclusion Without Sufficient Experimental Facts
Because a) the group did not perform condensing calorimetry, b) it used
an unsuitable device to measure steam quality, c) it did not check that
liquid water did not flow out of the device and down the drain, and d)
it did not write a scientific report about its one experiment below the
boiling point of water, it had no quantitative facts about the amount or
quality of steam.
As a result, the group could not know the amount of energy production within an order of magnitude.
As with any scientific claim, the burden to provide convincing evidence rests with the claimant.
[Ed: This document was updated on Aug. 9, 2011 to improve the clarity of the two measurement methods.]
|
|
|
|
|